There’s vinyl in my future. felttip: dwineman: strutting: via Chockenberry, the damage record companies have wrought on the Rolling Stones masterpiece Exile on Main Street. LET’S MAKE EVERYTHING LOUDER YEAH THATLL SOUND GREAT … … buncha jerks. Wow. What’s going on here is that in remastering (top soundwave), the audio has been distorted (via compression and amplification) so much that basically everything is the same volume. There’s no dynamic range; every instant of sound is now at peak loudness. One of the greatest recordings of all time has been made harsh, dull, and tiring to listen to because record company executives want it to sound “loud.” It’s hard to tell from this graphic, but it looks like there may even be some clipping going on. See where the waveform is flattened against the top and bottom of the window? That’s audio data being amplified to the point of becoming indistinguishable noise. Normally when this happens, it’s a mistake: some piece of equipment is turned up too loud, overdriving the thing it’s plugged into. You turn it down, the clipping goes away. But when the clipping is part of the recording, it just sounds like dogshit at every volume level, forever.1 I’ll be keeping my non-remastered, non-ruined copy, thanks. Wayback Machine link because the original, classic Rip Rowan article seems to have disappeared. ↩ I’ve been aware of the Loudness Wars ever since Sound Studio came out in 1999. One of the reasons people preferred the vinyl versions of songs over the remastered CDs is because of this, and they would transfer their vinyl to digital with apps like mine. But it’s worth reblogging for all the new people who aren’t aware of this.

There’s vinyl in my future.

felttip:

dwineman:

strutting:

via Chockenberry, the damage record companies have wrought on the Rolling Stones masterpiece Exile on Main Street. LET’S MAKE EVERYTHING LOUDER YEAH THATLL SOUND GREAT …

… buncha jerks.

Wow.

What’s going on here is that in remastering (top soundwave), the audio has been distorted (via compression and amplification) so much that basically everything is the same volume. There’s no dynamic range; every instant of sound is now at peak loudness. One of the greatest recordings of all time has been made harsh, dull, and tiring to listen to because record company executives want it to sound “loud.”

It’s hard to tell from this graphic, but it looks like there may even be some clipping going on. See where the waveform is flattened against the top and bottom of the window? That’s audio data being amplified to the point of becoming indistinguishable noise. Normally when this happens, it’s a mistake: some piece of equipment is turned up too loud, overdriving the thing it’s plugged into. You turn it down, the clipping goes away. But when the clipping is part of the recording, it just sounds like dogshit at every volume level, forever.1

I’ll be keeping my non-remastered, non-ruined copy, thanks.

  1. Wayback Machine link because the original, classic Rip Rowan article seems to have disappeared. ↩

I’ve been aware of the Loudness Wars ever since Sound Studio came out in 1999. One of the reasons people preferred the vinyl versions of songs over the remastered CDs is because of this, and they would transfer their vinyl to digital with apps like mine. But it’s worth reblogging for all the new people who aren’t aware of this.

41 notes

Show

  1. tackazvezda reblogged this from dwineman
  2. 003labs reblogged this from felttip and added:
    This is why you avoid “DIGITALLY REMASTERED!” versions: bye bye dynamics. felttip:
  3. matchbradford reblogged this from dwineman
  4. ilikestuff reblogged this from felttip and added:
    There’s vinyl in my future.
  5. dbreunig reblogged this from felttip and added:
    I wish they would badge these ‘remasters’ as ‘remastered for small earbuds.’ Then sell original, high quality transfers...
  6. bcbishop reblogged this from felttip
  7. peroty reblogged this from felttip
  8. felttip reblogged this from dwineman and added:
    I’ve been aware of the Loudness Wars ever since Sound Studio came out in 1999. One of the reasons people preferred the...
  9. shanecyr reblogged this from dwineman and added:
    What you’re seeing there is very likely aggressive soft-knee limiting, which, while also highly effective for ruining...
  10. dwineman reblogged this from strutting and added:
    Wow. What’s going on here is that in remastering (top soundwave),...company executives...
  11. strutting posted this